Unknown's avatar

About thebellyofthebeast

Adjunct professor at Northwestern University Law School, regular contributor to Bill Moyers.com, Dan Rather’s “News & Guts,” and "Common Dreams," creator/curator of the Trump-Russia-Ukraine Timeline, the Insurrection Timeline, and the Pandemic Timeline series at “Moyers on Democracy" (The Trump-Russia-Ukraine Timeline also appears at “Just Security”) and author of "The Lawyer Bubble - A Profession in Crisis (2013), "The Partnership - A Novel" (2010), "Crossing Hoffa - A Teamster's Story" (2007) (A "Chicago Tribune" Best Book of the Year), and "Straddling Worlds: The Jewish-American Journey of Professor Richard W. Leopold" (2008). Retired after 30 years at Kirkland & Ellis LLP. Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers. Graduated from Harvard Law School (magna cum laude) and Northwestern University (combined B.A./M.A. in economics, with distinction and Phi Beta Kappa).

THE UGLY AFTERMATH OF CHARLIE KIRK’S ASSASSINATION

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on September 21, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

In the final minutes of FBI Director Kash Patel’s appearance before the Senate Judiciary Committee on September 16, Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC) acknowledged the obvious: Individuals on the left should not have celebrated Charlie Kirk’s assassination, but influential voices on the right were inflaming the situation.

The bottom line, Tillis observed, was that escalation of the rhetoric on the right was making the FBI’s job of law enforcement more difficult.

Trump Disagrees

Sen. Tillis’s analysis would have come as a shock to President Donald Trump, who blamed the episode on the “radical left.” Speaking Wednesday night from the Oval office only hours after Kirk’s death on September 10 – before the identity or motives of the assassin were known – he issued a video message from the Oval Office:

“My administration will find each and every one of those who contributed to this atrocity and to other political violence, including the organizations that fund it and support it, as well as those who go after our judges, law enforcement officials, and everyone else who brings order to our country.”

Listing recent attacks against himself and other conservative figures, he didn’t mention violence against Democrats, including: the assassination of a Minnesota lawmaker and her husband; the shooting of another Minnesota legislator and his wife; the arson attack on Gov. Josh Shapiro’s (D-PA) residence; or the attack on Rep. Nancy Pelosi’s (D-CA) husband. Those omissions were an important tell: Trump is going after Democrats.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/the-ugly-aftermath-of-charlie-kirks

FLORIDA’S ANTI-VAX MYSOGYNY AND TRUMP’S HYPOCRISY

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on September 11, 2025.]

The Florida surgeon general believes you have sovereignty over your own body… unless you’re a woman! Meanwhile, Trump’s Jeffrey Epstein headache worsens as he makes money selling the Trump Bible.

by Steven J. Harper

On September 3, Florida Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo made news again. With a grinning Gov. Ron DeSantis (R-FL) at his side, he announced that his state would no longer require vaccines for children. Even more shocking were Dr. Ladapo’s subsequent admissions on national television.

Laced throughout were Republican hypocrisy and misogyny to which President Donald Trump added an exclamation point a few days later.

“A Gift From God”

Describing Florida’s new anti-vaccine policy, Dr. Ladapo said, “Your body is a gift from God.” He added that the administration would be “working to end” all vaccine mandates. “Every last one of them is wrong and drips with disdain and slavery.”

On September 7, he tried to defend his actions on CNN’s State of the Union:

Anchor Jake Tapper: “Before you made this decision to lift vaccine mandates for Florida, which include obviously public schools, did your department do any data analysis, did you do any data projections of how many new cases of these diseases there will be in Florida, once you remove vaccine mandates?”

Ladapo: “Absolutely not….There is this conflation of the science and sort of what is the right and wrong thing to do… I’m saying it’s an issue of right and wrong.”

Tapper confronted Dr. Ladapo with facts: 82% of Florida parents with kids in school wanted mandatory vaccines for children; every medical organization in the country (AMA, American Academy of Pediatrics, Florida Medical Association) urged mandatory vaccines for children; and even Florida Sen. Rick Scott (R) supported Florida’s existing vaccine mandate, which allows religious exemptions.

Tapper: “All of these people are wrong, and you’re right.”

Ladapo: “Casting it in that way is not what I would do. It’s not how I would look at it.”

Dr. Ladapo then explained why facts don’t matter: “I share what is the right thing to do. Whether it’s popular or not…. It’s really about ethics. Is it really appropriate for a government or any other entity to dictate to you what you should put in your body? It is absolutely not appropriate.”

Then came Dr. Ladapo’s money quote: “You have sovereignty over your body.”

He forgot an important GOP caveat: Unless you’re a woman.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/floridas-anti-vax-mysogyny-and-trumps

ROBERT F. KENNEDY JR.’s DEADLY OBSESSION

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on September 1, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

Vaccines have saved millions of lives. But for decades, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has pursued a single-minded crusade against them. Numerous scientific studies have debunked his false claim that vaccines cause autism. But now he’s weaponizing the nation’s public health system to promote his ideological quackery.

Once a Crackpot, Always a Crackpot – But Now Possessing the Power of Life and Death

· In a 2021 podcast, Kennedy urged Americans to “resist” CDC guidelines on when kids should get vaccines.

· In 2021, Kennedy said, “I see somebody on a hiking trail carrying a little baby and I say to him, better not get them vaccinated.”

· In a video promoting his non-profit organization’s anti-vaccine sticker campaign, Kennedy appeared onscreen next to a sticker that declared “IF YOU’RE NOT AN ANTI-VAXXER YOU AREN’T PAYING ATTENTION.”

· In a July 2023 podcast, he said, “There’s no vaccine that is, you know, safe and effective.”

Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA), a physician, knows that Kennedy’s anti-vaccine claims are bogus. But Kennedy assured him that he would protect “the public health benefit of vaccinations” and maintain without changes the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP). That committee of outside experts reviews the most recent data on all vaccines to assess safety, efficacy, and clinical need. It develops a recommended guidance schedule for all vaccines, including seasonal flu shots and COVID boosters. Physicians rely on that guidance in counseling patients, and insurance companies and government programs use it to determine the vaccines they will cover.

Based on Kennedy’s promises, Sen. Cassidy cast the deciding vote to confirm him as Secretary of Health and Human Services.

Timeline of Destruction

In RFK Jr.’s mission to spread his lies, he has systematically gutted the world’s premier public health organization.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/robert-f-kennedy-jrs-deadly-obsession

A TIMELINE OF TRUMP’S FUTILE EPSTEIN DIVERSIONS

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on August 27, 2025.]

A Timeline of Trump’s Futile Epstein Diversions

by Steven J. Harper

Drip, drip, drip…

For months, Trump has tried to divert public attention from the Jeffrey Epstein/Ghislane Maxwell files. But he can’t shake the story, and it keeps getting worse.

The Reversal

Trump campaigned for the presidency on the promise to release all of the files relating to Epstein’s sex trafficking in minors. To supercharge his MAGA base, he fueled conspiracy theories that the files contained something sinister involving prominent Democrats.

February 2025: Trump’s attorney general, Pam Bondi, told a Fox News interviewer that Epstein’s client list was sitting on her desk, awaiting her review before its release.

May: Bondi and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche informed Trump that his name appeared in the Epstein files, The New York Times later reported.

July 7: FBI Director Kash Patel – who had also pushed conspiracy theories about the files during Trump’s campaign – issued a two-page memo stating that there was no Epstein client list and that the Justice Department would not release any additional materials relating to the matter.

July 16: Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York Maurene Comey was fired. Comey was a lead prosecutor in the investigation and prosecution of Epstein and his co-conspirator, Ghislane Maxwell. She was also the daughter of former FBI Director James Comey and chief of the Violent and Organized Crime Unit. The memo gave no reason for Comey’s abrupt termination.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/a-timeline-of-trumps-futile-epstein

TRUMP’S DESPERATE, ANTI-DEMOCRATIC QUEST TO RETAIN POWER

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on August 19, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

President Donald Trump and Republicans face a daunting challenge: How to preserve power in the wake of their wildly unpopular policies? Their strategy is to intensify the GOP’s decades-long quest to limit voter participation. Selecting the voters likely to cast ballots for them is far better than letting all voters select their leaders.

Trump has taken the strategy to a whole new level. And he’s doing it out of fear and desperation.

Fighting History

During midterm elections, the president’s party loses seats in Congress. In Trump’s first term, Republicans lost 40 seats in the House in 2018. In 2010, President Barack Obama’s Democrats lost 63.

The exceptions are few and far between. In the aftermath of 9/11, President George W. Bush’s GOP gained eight House seats in 2002, but then lost 30 in 2006. In 1998, President Bill Clinton’s Democrats gained five seats, but that didn’t offset the 52 seats that they had lost in 1994. In all but three midterm elections from 1934 to 1994 – from Franklin Roosevelt to Bill Clinton – the president’s party lost House seats. It did a little better in the Senate, gaining seats in only six of 23 midterm elections since 1934.

With Republicans holding a slim 219-212 majority heading into the 2026 midterms, Trump has every reason to panic at what awaits him in 15 months.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/trumps-desperate-anti-democratic

THE LATEST CHAPTER IN THE GHISLANE MAXWELL SAGA

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on August14, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

When we left convicted sex offender Ghislane Maxwell, she had just received several remarkable gifts from the Trump administration.

First, while serving a 20-year sentence for sex trafficking minors as Jeffrey Epstein’s procurer, she got an unprecedented meeting with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche, the second highest official in the Justice Department. Blanche was also President Donald Trump’s personal lawyer in the hush-money trial resulting in his 34 felony convictions. That such a meeting even occurred astonished legal observers across the political spectrum.

Second, only a week later, the Justice Department’s Bureau of Prisons transferred Maxwell out of the Florida Correctional Institution in Tallahassee, a minimum security prison with horrendous conditions. Her new home is the Federal Prison Camp in Bryan, Texas – a “Club Fed” that houses white-collar criminals and celebrities who have far better living quarters and relative freedom of movement.

The Plot Thickens

Now independent journalist and podcast host Allison Gill (“Mueller, She Wrote” on Bluesky) reports, “I have Ghislaine Maxwell’s security score, custody level, transfer code, public safety factor, and sex offender waiver.”’

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

MORE ON THE GHISLANE MAXWELL SCANDAL

My August 5, 2025 interview with Ian Masters on Background Briefing is available here: https://www.backgroundbriefing.org

GHILSLANE MAXWELL SEEMS TO HAVE NEW FRIENDS IN HIGH PLACES

[This article first appeared on Common Dreams on August 3, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

On July 24 and 25, convicted sex offender Ghislane Maxwell met with Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche – the number two official in the Department of Justice. At the time, Maxwell was three years into her 20-year sentence at the Federal Correctional Institute in Tallahassee, Florida (FCI Tallahassee). A week later, the Bureau of Prisons – an agency of the Department of Justice – confirmed that she’d been transferred to the Federal Prison Camp at Bryan, Texas (FPC Bryan).

It’s not a pardon, but it’s a big improvement in her quality of life. 

On the outside, it’s the difference between double-fenced barbed wire and a wrought iron fence akin to that of a gated community. On the inside, the differences are more dramatic.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/ghislane-maxwell-seems-to-have-new

THE EPSTEIN CONSPIRACY FLAMES THAT TRUMP FANNED ARE NOW BLOWING BACK ON HIM

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on July 29, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

On August 10, 2019, Jeffrey Epstein – accused of sex trafficking in minor girls – committed suicide in his jail cell while awaiting trial, and a new conspiracy theory was born: Powerful forces silenced him. Releasing the Justice Department’s files on Epstein would reveal a “client list” of high-profile individuals, including prominent Democrats, who had a motive to kill him.

Then-President Donald Trump jumped aboard the conspiracy bandwagon. Six years later, he’s now trying desperately to stop it.

Setting the Stage

Hours after Epstein’s death, Trump retweeted a post alleging that Bill Clinton was connected to Epstein’s death. Trump’s supporters dutifully followed his lead:

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/the-epstein-conspiracy-flames-that

REMEMBERING BILL MOYERS

Here’s my July 21, 2025 interview discussing Bill Moyers: Radio Parallax with Doug Ellison:
https://radioparallax.com/single-shows/5740/

STEPHEN COLBERT’S FIRING: THE CRITICAL UNANSWERED QUESTION

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on July 21, 2025.]

Stephen Colbert’s Firing: The Critical Unanswered Question

by Steven J. Harper

Timing is everything.

The news that The Late Show with Stephen Colbert will end in May 2026 has focused on whether his termination was part of a “deal” (implicit or explicit) to get Federal Communications Commission approval of the pending merger between CBS’s parent company Paramount and Skydance Media. If so, it was another “bend-the-knee” moment in the media’s ongoing capitulation to Trump’s attack on democracy’s foundational institutions.

But the timing of the announcement itself is raises a critical unanswered question: Why now? It was either pandering to President Donald Trump, management’s incompetence, or both.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/stephen-colberts-firing-the-critical

THE TRAGEDY OF THOM TILLIS

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on July 15, 2025.]

The Tragedy of Thom Tillis

by Steven J. Harper

The incompetence of President Donald Trump’s Secretary of Defense is painfully obvious. Former Fox & Friends weekend host Pete Hegseth was never qualified for the job. Belatedly, Sen. Thom Tillis (R-NC) – who became the key vote to confirm the nominee – now admits it.

Tillis squandered a unique opportunity to protect the nation from Hegseth. The country is now paying the price for his cowardice.

Tillis’s Reversal

In a phone call with Trump just before Christmas, Tillis promised to support all of Trump’s cabinet picks. But he developed strong reservations about Pete Hegseth – strong enough to participate in a secret effort to kill the nomination. Serious issues about character, statements about barring women in combat, and allegations of sexual misconduct dogged Hegseth. He had none of the qualifications necessary to run the defense department of more than two million military and civilian personnel.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/the-tragedy-of-thom-tillis

A PERSONAL TRIBUTE TO BILL MOYERS, WHO NEVER STOPPED PUSHING

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on June 30, 2025.]

A Personal Tribute to Bill Moyers, Who Never Stopped Pushing

by Steven J. Harper

On June 26, America lost an iconic force for good. I lost a great friend.

A Life of Public Service

partial summary of Bill Moyers’ impressive life fills entire pages of The New York Times and The Washington Post – treatment reserved for royalty and rock stars. Bill was both.

In those pages you’ll read about his illustrious political career as President Lyndon Johnson’s special assistant, press secretary, and key architect of the “Great Society” – a collection of programs that are now in danger, including the War on Poverty that produced Medicare, Medicaid, the Food Stamp Act and the Economic Opportunity Act; the Civil Rights Act of 1964; the Voting Rights Act of 1965; the National Foundation on the Arts and the Humanities Act of 1965, and more.

You’ll marvel at his unparalleled journalism that resulted in landmark documentaries, best-selling books, dozens of EmmyAwards, two Alfred I. Dupont-Columbia University Awards, nine Peabody Awards, three George Polk Awards, and the first-ever Honorary Doctor of Fine Arts from the American Film Institute.

A Source of Private Inspiration

I’m going to cover different ground that you won’t find anywhere else. During the final years of Bill’s life, I had the honor of working directly with him on one of his most important missions: preserving democracy.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://substack.com/inbox/post/167185823?triedRedirect=true

TRUMP’S ONE BIG BEAUTIFUL (UGLY) BILL VERSUS AN UNSUNG HERO

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on June 25, 2025.]

Trump’s One Big Beautiful (Ugly) Bill v. An Unsung Hero

by Steven J. Harper

In the dead of night at 2:53 a.m. on May 22, the House of Representatives began to consider President Donald Trump’s “One Big Beautiful Bill Act.” 

Four hours later, Republicans passed it by a single vote – 215 to 214. It included a provision that effectively forgave most of Trump’s unconstitutional actions and undermined the federal courts. 

Republicans in the Senate made it worse.

Over the weekend, an unlikely hero blocked this assault on the Constitution: the Senate parliamentarian. Will her ruling stick? Or will Senate Republicans detonate the “nuclear option” to save the provision?

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://www.commondreams.org/opinion/trump-bill-vs-parliamentarian

RFK Jr.’s GUIDE TO MAKING AMERICA SICK AGAIN

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on June 15, 2025.]

RFK Jr. STRIKES AGAIN – AT AMERICANS’ HEALTH

by Steven J. Harper

Someone should have told Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy that President Donald Trump’s mishandling of the last pandemic probably cost him the presidency in 2020. Building on his longstanding anti-vaxxing crusade, Kennedy has followed a three-step program that will worsen the next outbreak.

Step 1: Reduce vaccine availability. Three weeks ago, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) – one of Kennedy’s HHS agencies – announced that for healthy Americans under 65, COVID vaccines will not be approved until they pass large scale and time-consuming clinical trials. That is a daunting obstacle.

Step 2: Reduce vaccine eligibility. The following week, Kennedy announced that the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) would no longer recommend the COVID vaccine for children and pregnant women. Within days, the CDC had to walk it back somewhat, stating that whether to vaccinate a child should be the product of “shared decision-making” involving parents and physicians. But pregnant women remain in the limbo world of “no recommendation.” In any event, the negative impact on overall public health will be enormous.

Step 3: Eliminate vaccine expertise. On June 9, Kennedy fired the entire CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) – all 17 of them. This committee of outside experts reviews the most recent data on all vaccines to assess safety, efficacy, and clinical need. It develops a recommended guidance schedule for all vaccines, including seasonal flu shots and COVID boosters. Physicians rely on that guidance in counseling patients, and insurance companies and government programs use it to determine the vaccines they will cover. Committee members received their termination notices via email sent two hours after Kennedy announced their firing in a Wall Street Journal op-ed.

With Kennedy’s selection of his first eight replacements on June 11, we’re getting a sense of the disaster that will accompany Step 4.

[[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/rfk-jrs-guide-to-making-america-sick

RFK Jr.’s DEADLY WAR ON SCIENCE

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on June –, 2025.]

RFK Jr.’s Deadly War on Science

by Steven J. Harper

During an NBC interview on November 6, Robert F. Kennedy Jr. was cleaning up his lifelong anti-vaccination act as he lobbied to become Health and Human Services Secretary in the Trump administration.

“If vaccines are working for somebody, I’m not going to take them away,” he said. “People ought to have choice…”

Kennedy is not a doctor or a scientist, but he got the job as America’s top public health officer. Now he’s making the wrong choices for all of us.

[[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/rfk-jrs-deadly-war-on-science

TRUMP AND HIS BIG LAW FIRMS KEEP LOSING

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on May 27, 2025.]

Trump and his Big Law Firms Keep Losing

by Steven J. Harper

President Donald Trump and the Big Law firms that surrendered to his unconstitutional executive orders suffered another bad week.

Trump Loses Again

In a 52-page opinion, U.S. District Court Judge John D. Bates – a 2001 appointee of President George W. Bush – rejected the Justice Department’s effort to defend Trump’s executive order targeting Jenner & Block. Trump’s own words doomed it: 

Like the others in the series, this order—which takes aim at the global law firm Jenner & Block— makes no bones about why it chose its target: it picked Jenner because of the causes Jenner champions, the clients Jenner represents, and a lawyer Jenner once employed. (Jenner & Block v. U.S. Department of Justice, et al. Civil Action No. 25-916 (JDB) p. 1)

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page (No paywall)]:

https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/trump-and-his-big-law-firms-keep

LAURA LOOMER: TRUMP WHISPERER

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on May 22, 2025.]

Laura Loomer: Trump Whisperer

Meet the influential right-wing conspiracy theorist who has U.S. President Donald Trump’s ear.

by Steven J. Harper

Laura Loomer is 31 years old and a graduate of Barry University, a private Catholic university. A former commentator on Alex Jones’s Infowars and a far-right conspiracy theorist, she has 1.5 million followers on X. Loomer traffics in anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant rhetoric. She has called herself a “proud Islamophobe” and “pro-white nationalism.”

And she has President Donald Trump’s ear.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]:

https://substack.com/inbox/post/164101951

BIG LAW DEALS WITH TRUMP ARE BACKFIRING ON TOP FIRMS

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on May 15,.2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

The Big Law firms that capitulated to President Donald Trump’s unconstitutional demands thought they were buying peace with his administration, preserving their client relationships, and protecting their bottom lines.

Recent developments illustrate the growing magnitude of their mistake.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]:

LAWYERS BEHAVING BADLY

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on May 4, 2025.]

LAWYERS BEHAVING BADLY

by Steven J. Harper

President Donald Trump directed Attorney General Pam Bondi “to seek sanctions against attorneys and law firms who engage in frivolous, unreasonable, and vexatious litigation,” including legal filings for improper purposes and statements that are not based on evidence.

Bondi should start with the White House attorneys who drafted Trump’s executive orders targeting Big Law firms – and her Justice Department lawyers trying to defend them.

Did Real Lawyers Write These Orders?

Cloaked in empty rhetoric about “conduct detrimental to critical American interests,” retribution is at the core of Trump’s edicts.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/lawyers-behaving-badly

HOW A PROFESSIONAL BULLY IS WINNING CONTROL OF THE MEDIA

Major media outlets from CBS to The Washington Post have “bent the knee” to President Trump’s specious demands.

{This article first appeared at Common Dreams on April 25, 2025.]

President Donald Trump is following the authoritarian’s handbook that Prime Minister Viktor Orbán used to consolidate power in Hungary. He is attacking the independent institutions that comprise the infrastructure supporting democracy – universities, law firms, culture, and the media.

And he is winning.

Major media outlets have “bent the knee” – his press secretary’s preferred phrase for capitulation to Trump’s specious demands. His latest conquest is CBS.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://substack.com/home/post/p-162047741

HOW TO BEAT A PRESIDENTIAL BULLY

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on April 18, 2025.]

While Columbia University capitulated to Trump’s demands, Harvard is offering U.S. institutions a lesson in fighting back.

by Steven J. Harper

Harvard University is providing a lesson that most children learn in elementary school but many leaders of America’s most important institutions have forgotten: The only effective way to deal with a bully is to fight back.

Trump’s Pretext

Columbia University was the first target in Trump’s disingenuous crusade against antisemitism. Disingenuous because he claimed that the school’s failures caused Jewish students to feel unsafe. His supposed remedy – withholding $400 million in federal funds – is a non sequitur.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://open.substack.com/pub/stevenjharper/p/how-to-beat-a-presidential-bully?r=1tno6t&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

THIS IS THE LEGAL PROFESSION’S MCCARTHY MOMENT

by Steven J. Harper

Author’s update: This article first appeared at Crain’s Chicago Business on April 9, 2025. Since then, five more Big Law firms have capitulated to Trump’s unconstitutional demands: Kirkland & Ellis, Latham & Watkins, A&O Shearman, Simpson Thacher & Bartlett and Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft agreed to do free legal work on causes the White House supports, including those with “conservative ideals.” 

Combined with the firms that have previously bent their knees to Trump, those five recent Big Law cowards now bring Trump’s war chest to $940 million in pro bono that some of the best attorneys in the country must now provide for Trump-approved causes. Trump himself gave two examples: working on trade and coal-leasing deals. 

Another firm – Susman Godfrey – has joined the ranks of those who have challenged Trump’s unlawful edit. Munger, Tolles & Olson is representing that firm.

Above the Law is tracking all of the top 200 firms. Here’s that link: https://abovethelaw.com/2025/04/biglaw-is-under-attack-heres-what-the-firms-are-doing-about-it/

I suspect that law students will view it with great interest, as they should.

***

The nation’s biggest law firms are trying to avoid a confrontation with a rogue president’s unconstitutional demands. They can run, but they can’t hide.

Three firms have fought back. More than 500 others signed a legal brief opposing Trump’s executive orders targeting Big Law – the profession’s biggest and most lucrative firms. But only 10 of the top 100 revenue-generating firms joined. None of the top 20 stepped up, including the firm where I practiced for almost 30 years, Kirkland & Ellis.

None.

I understand the conspicuous silence at the financial pinnacle of the profession. With partners earning multimillion dollar incomes, money is the glue that holds them together. They have the resources to resist, but can’t escape the clutches of their own greed.

Their business models are fragile because partners have created portable client silos. If partners leave, they can take those clients with them and firm profits will suffer. If enough lawyers leave, the institution can unravel quickly.

With a myopic focus on partner profits, firm leaders don’t see the big picture: Appeasement doesn’t deter bullies; it empowers them. Most Big Law partners have also forgotten why they went to law school in the first place, along with their sworn oaths to defend the Constitution and the rule of law.

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://open.substack.com/pub/stevenjharper/p/this-is-the-legal-professions-mccarthy?r=1tno6t&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

TRUMP’S THIRD TERM – DISTRACTION OR POWER PLAY?

[This post first appeared at Common Dreams on April 8, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

“No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice….”

The 22nd Amendment to the Constitution restored the two-term tradition that President George Washington established. Except for Franklin D. Roosevelt during World War II, every president since Washington has followed it. President Donald Trump talks about breaking it.

Is he just waiving another shiny object at all of us? Or is he previewing his ultimate power play? With Trump, it’s always best to assume the worst. 

[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/trumps-third-term-distraction-or

THE ONE-WORD REASON PAUL WEISS CAVED TO TRUMP

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on March 28, 2025.]

by Steven J. Harper

The decision was a culminating event in Big Law’s transformation from a noble profession to a collection of profit-maximizing businesses.

1,613.

That’s how many words Brad Karp, chairman of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP, used in his March 23 memo defending his firm’s capitulation to President Donald Trump.

One would have been enough: greed.

Observers have been shocked and puzzled at Paul Weiss’s refusal to fight Trump’s unconstitutional order aimed at destroying the firm. But its decision was a culminating event in Big Law’s transformation from a noble profession to a collection of profit-maximizing businesses.

The Big Law business model values only what it can measure. And there’s no metric for defending the Constitution, preserving democracy, or upholding the rule of law.

…[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://open.substack.com/pub/stevenjharper/p/the-one-word-reason-paul-weiss-caved

WHY SCHUMER SHOULD RESIGN NOW

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on March 17, 2025.]

At this critical inflection point for democracy, America cannot afford a rudderless resistance from a compromised leader.

Maybe Democratic New York Senator Chuck Schumer was correct.

Maybe it was more important for him to align himself with President Donald TrumpElon Musk, and congressional Republicans than to resist them with one of the few weapons that Democrats possess—the Senate filibuster.

Maybe calling the Republicans’ bluff to shut down the government would have been worse than the pain that Trump, Musk, and their allies continue to inflict on the nation and the world.

Or maybe Schumer just blew it.

…[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://stevenjharper.substack.com/p/why-schumer-should-resign-now

TRUMP ATTACKS THE RIGHT TO A LAWYER

[This article first appeared at Common Dreams on March 12 2025.]

The presidential assault on the lawyers and law firms representing his litigation adversaries is an attack on the very foundation of the legal system.

In America’s legal system, both sides to a dispute are entitled to counsel. President Donald Trump rejects that premise because he prefers a one-sided battle that he is more likely to win.

To that end, he is using his special ability to combine vindictiveness with strategy. Wielding the power of the presidency, he is penalizing the attorneys who represent his opponents. Even more troubling, other lawyers are helping him undermine the foundation of our justice system.

…[To continue reading, please click here to reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://open.substack.com/pub/stevenjharper/p/trump-attacks-the-right-to-a-lawyer?r=1tno6t&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

PUTIN’S USEFUL IDIOTS AMBUSH DEMOCRACY

{This article first appeared at Common Dreams on March 4, 2025.]

“This is going to be great television.”

Putin and Trump

But it wasn’t great. It was tragic. U.S. President Donald Trump’s comment at the conclusion of his unprecedented public outburst directed toward Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy marked a milestone in a momentous week: Trump’s “America First” agenda became “America Alone… with Russia.”

Trump and Vice President JD Vance shouted at Zelenskyy—a beleaguered wartime leader struggling to defend his democratic nation against Russia’s invasion. They scolded him for not thanking Trump, who slowed to a trickle the flow of American weapons to Ukraine.

In rejecting Trump’s request, Zelenskyy joined Trump’s list of “enemies.” To get even, Trump is now helping Russia negotiate what it could not achieve after three years on the battlefield: the conquest of Ukraine.

…[To continue reading, please click here tp reach my Substack page. (No paywall)]: https://substack.com/home/post/p-158410517

JEFF BEZOS IS GREASING AMERICA’S SLIDE TOWARD AUTOCRACY

(This article first appeared at Common Dreams on February 26, 2025.)

Titans like Bezos who control mainstream media are pandering to Trump in ways that compromise their publications.

Billionaires controlling key elements of the media are helping U.S. President Donald Trump establish an authoritarian regime. Jeff Bezos, owner of The Washington Post, has become a poster child for the phenomenon. 

American democracy may be a casualty.

Please continue reading on my Substack page (It’s free. No paywall.):

https://open.substack.com/pub/stevenjharper/p/jeff-bezos-is-greasing-americas-slide?r=1tno6t&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true

SPECIAL ANNOUNCEMENT TO MY READERS

I’m moving my blog to Substack.

It won’t have a paywall, so you can continue to read my articles without charge.

During a transitional period, I’ll post portions of my articles here (at “The Belly of the Beast”) and include a link inviting you to continue reading at my Substack page.

I greatly appreciate your ongoing support. I hope you’ll continue following me by subscribing to my Substack account. You can use this link: https://substack.com/@stevenjharper